Ahmad Rida Khan refuted on the earth being stationary


Often, the lovers of Ahmad Rida Khan give him a status of even a scientist. One of his blunders surrounding science, is his claim that the earth is stationary and the sun moves around it. This claim, was refuted centuries ago by the scholars and unfortunately Ahmad Raza Khan revived this innovation.

By Shaykh Naeem Abdul Wali:

Here is one of Raza Khan’s writings proving the Earth is stationary and the Sun, etc orbit it. Now please do NOT go off on silly tangents, but the English translation is challenging to say the least, so trying to understand his arguments at least in this pdf is really difficult, any one want to take it on and refute it?

http://www.barkati.net/book/english/Complete_AFairSuccess.pdf

Source: www.facebook.com/gary.l.edwards.9/posts/10153427878860710

By Sh. Hani Ali:

هل صحّ أن أحمد رضا خان البريلوي كفر كل من قال بدوران الأرض حول الشمس ؟؟

إن صحّ فهي مصيبة ومثال واضح لأهمية التفريق بين “قداسة النص” و “فهم النص” بغض النظر عن هوية من صدر عنه الفهم وقدره ولو كان من أعلم أهل زمانه كما هو حال أحمد رضا البريلوي .
ويتأكد هذا التفريق عندما يتعلق فهم النص بأمور كونية أو علوم تجريبية لا تميز فيها لمؤمن على كافر .

لا أصدق أنه يوجد في زماننا هذا من ينشر هذا الكلام ويعتقده فقط لأنه صدر عن أحمد رضا البريلوي !!

Source: http://www.facebook.com/hani.hussein/posts/10151725889087401

Advertisements

2 Responses to Ahmad Rida Khan refuted on the earth being stationary

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: