Names of scholars who were against mawlid


 Names of scholars who were against mawlid: 

1. Mujaddid Alf-i-Sani Shaykh Ahmad Sirhindi

2. Imam Shatibi al-Gharnati al-Maliki

3. ‘Allamah Qadi Shihab al-Din Dolatabadi Hanafi, Sahib Tafsir Bahr al-Mawaj

4. ‘Allamah Muhammad bin Fazal Jonpuri

5. ‘Allamah Qadi Nasir al-Din Gujrati

6. ‘Allamah Taaj al-Din Fakhani al-Maliki

7. Hafiz Abul Hassan ‘Ali bin Fazal Maliki

8. Shaykh Ibn al-Haaj Maliki

9. Hafiz Ibn Taymiyyah

10. Shaykh ‘Abd al-Rahman Maghribi

11. Imam Nasir al-Din Shafi’i

12. ‘Allamah Sharf al-Din Hanbali known as Qadi Jabal.

13. Shaykh Nur al-Din Sharalmsi in Sharh Mawahib al-Laduniyyah

14. ‘Allamah Hassan bin ‘Ali

15. Shaykh Ahmad bin Muhammad Maliki

16. ‘Allamah Abul Qasim ‘Abd al-Rahman Maliki

17. Shaykh ‘Usman Dan Fodio Maliki

18. Shaykh Muhammad bin Abu Bakar Makhzumi Maliki

19. ‘Allamah ‘Alu al-Din ibn Isma’il Shafi’i

20. Hafiz Abu Bakar known as Ibn Nukta Baghdadi

21. Shaykh ibn Rajab Efindi, Sahib Sharh Tariqah Muhammadiyyah

22. ‘Allamah Fakhr al-Din Khurasani

23. Shaykh ‘Abd al-Wahhab Sha’rani

24. Sahib Nur al-Yaqin

25. Sahib Tariqah Muhammadiyyah

26. Imam Anwar Shah Kashmiri

27. Imam Rasheed Ahmad Gangohi

28. Hakim al-Ummah Mawlana Thanwi

There are some scholars who allowed mawlid but were againt qiyam during the mawlid and considered it bid’ah.

1. ‘Allamah Muhammad bin ‘Ali Dimishqi – student of ‘Allamah Suyuti

2. Hafiz Ibn Hajar Makki

Source: Marwajah Milad

Advertisements

19 Responses to Names of scholars who were against mawlid

  1. muhanmod says:

    salam

    Please add

    ibn katheer
    hajar asqalani

    for more info look at Ali Gommas website and Zuhaylys website

  2. Allamah Ahmed Sadiq Desai, Mufti Ebrahim Salejee, Mufti Hashim Bhoda, Mufti Yunus Patel, etc..are all against mawlid

  3. The source isn’t working

  4. muhammod says:

    Salam

    I love the bit when he mentions suyuti. Mawlid is not only about standing, according to your artcles

  5. Abul Hussain says:

    Search for Abu Hasan Barelwi and his Co, like Suleiman ibn Salim Bobat & Abdal-Qadir in the video below:

    Barelwi takfiris said:
    these french are a lesser evil than those zindiq, Islam-hating wahabis who were in power for some time. some of the stuff they did is far worse. may Allah destroy wahabis everywhere.

    may Allah ta’ala cleanse this earth from accursed wahabis. wherever they go they leave nothing but hatred, destruction and filth. only Allah ta’ala knows what the malayinah have done to the manuscripts in the two Harams.

    ———————————–

    So dancing and jumping like fools ( see those green turbaned fools ) is Islam ? I wonder who is really destroying Islam ?

    • muhammod says:

      Green is the clothes we gonna wear in paradise?

      Dancing, jumping, miltary training, sword fighting, football, olymipics are for fools?

      Check out the arab brewlewis

      • Abul Hussain says:

        I know of Green Turbaned Qadiyanis , oh forgot isn’t there some relation and connection between Qadiyanis and Barelwis ?

      • muhammod says:

        Green still equals paradise.
        Some or most qadiyanis have brown skin . A link with deobondis?

        Qadiyanis are hanafies. Link with deobondis?

      • Abul Hussain says:

        muhammod : Only a barelwi would say Qadiyanis are hanafis.

        The Creed of Hanafis is summarized by Imam Abu Jafer al-Tahawi ( whose creed also happens to refute the Barelwi Creed ) , so can you please tell me which Hanafis have believed what the associate of Barelwis Ghulam Ahmad Qadiyanis has said regarding Nubuwwat.

      • muhammod says:

        Presuming the green turban topic you ve dropped?! I knew it?!

        Didnt play the lame video. But noticed green on the picture. I could do that with my phone camera.

        Check out Hasan ali, Mufti Adam before commenting about aqida

      • muhammod says:

        http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ahmadiyya

        As for your question luckly i dont understand u but feel free to reject them

  6. Abul Hussain says:

    Gift to Barelwis

    Barelwis caught celebrating Mawlid — Meelad with their buddies in rites and rituals and superstitions

  7. The title of this article is misleading; to be against Mawlid and to be against the innovations that take place during Mawlid, are two different things.

    Ibn al-Hājj al-Mālikī and Shehu ‘Usmān Dan Fodio weren’t against Mawlid at all, but they were against Bid’ah. If we are gonna compile a list and establish a ruling based on that, then I am afraid the list of scholars that allowed Mawlid would exceed the list of those who opposed Mawlid.

    Was-Salām

    • Name(required) says:

      Your argument is illogical. You are basically saying, there are scholars who were not against an innovation but the innovations that take place during this innovation. Nonsense!

      • You are right. This person said that Mawlid is an innovation and saying that innovation that take place in Mawlid is baseless.First of All, according to the Deobandi Scholars (May Allah have mercy on him), A Mawlid free of reprehensive tasks is Mustahab (Recommended). Secondly, there is a good innovation too. Jamaat Ud dawa Wat Tabligh is a Good innovation. Mawlid is a good innvoation similarly. Actually your point is baseless.

    • You are right. This person said that Mawlid is an innovation and saying that innovation that take place in Mawlid is baseless.First of All, according to the Deobandi Scholars (May Allah have mercy on him), A Mawlid free of reprehensive tasks is Mustahab (Recommended). Secondly, there is a good innovation too. Jamaat Ud dawa Wat Tabligh is a Good innovation. Mawlid is a good innvoation similarly. Actually your point is baseless.

  8. sami ullah says:

    This is totally buhtan on Mujadid Alif sani r.a. i have myself read in his maktubat that Mawlid recitations, like quran and seerah and naat etc. i.e. veneration is not Prohibited.!

  9. […] author the “barelwism” blog (in https://barelwism.wordpress.com/2013/01/28/names-of-scholars-who-were-against-mawlid/) produced a list of scholars who he claims opposed the Mawlid. Although many of the scholars in the […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: